A Petri Dish Called Earth. 
      (Or - Why Should We Bother at All?) 
      It happens, now and 
      then, that when a microscopic organisms grow in a petri dish that a 
      some species starts suddenly taking over all the available 
      "lebensraum", crowding all the other cultures out, and suddenly disappears 
      after  having killed most of its fellow organisms, not having any 
      more room to expand in. It is wholly natural happening, observable also 
      during the stages of developing ecosystems before they reach a state of a 
      relative stability. A species suddenly flourishes, seemingly triumphing 
      over other species, to disappear in a blink of an eye, as if. This 
      phenomenon might happen a few times during ecological successions that 
      ensue when an ecological system gets disturbed from the outside of that 
      system, and that continues till the ecosystem reaches a state of a dynamic 
      balance in which ecological processes cycle around their mean 
      values.     Analogically, one could see the entire earth 
      system as being a vast petri dish that got disturbed from the outside by 
      an asteroid some sixty million years ago, whose impact caused the demise 
      of a vast number of faunal and floral species. Ever since then the earth 
      ecological system has been recovering from the disturbance, going through 
      successional stages that eventually will result in a relatively stable 
      climax, unless another asteroid, or other unusual catastrophe would cause 
      a process of re-stabilization  anew. And, as in any other isolated system that 
      is undergoing a process of stabilization, we might be able to discern the 
      evidence of species coming and going in ongoing successions. One of those 
      species in our giant petri dish earth is a hairless ape that is coming to 
      a prominence currently, one that started over-crowding the earth, crowding out 
      many other fellow "petri dish" species. Most likely this species will also 
      suddenly disappear after its bloom and will be replaced by some, till now 
      insignificant, contender. These goings-on will continue till the earth 
      system reaches a relative stability again, eventually (unless disturbed 
      from the outside of this relative system again, etc.). This currently 
      on earth dominant species is us, humans, of course, and we are not the 
      only species that happens to ever have been dominant (from time to time) 
      in our giant petri dish. Our behavior is nothing un-natural, we behave as 
      a myriad other species in a myriad of ecosystems would - we are fully 
      natural, and so is everything we do. We are an indelible part of the 
      nature. We might even expedite our own (and most of other species around 
      us) extinction, but that would be also fully natural, judging by what we 
      know about ecological developments. Looking at our earth petri dish from a 
      macroscopic point of view, business is always as usual. So - why should 
      anyone care about what humans are doing?     The answer is 
      that we, humans, should care, for purely selfish reasons, if we ever do care 
      about ourselves and about our offspring. It is very obvious that most 
      calamities and sufferings that humans are subject to are human made. 
      Humans are their own main source of their miseries. They are very much 
      like any microscopic organism (presumably non-intelligent) in a petri dish 
      that by its very own success as a species undermines its own future 
      continuity and well-being. Humans do not seem to be any different from any 
      such species, despite their own self-declared superiority to all other 
      life. We even call our own species "sapient" ("full of knowledge", 
      "sagacious", according to Webster's). This self-denomination, obviously, 
      is not true, judging by the overall human behavior which is not different 
      from the behavior of any "successful" species in any petri dish. It would 
      very much seem from observing life in petri dishes that the real recipe 
      for a real long term success for any truly intelligent species would be to 
      strive for a stability of existence of all the different microorganisms in 
      any petri dish, including the petri dish Earth, and if there is a real 
      intelligence in any petri dish (be it a glass one, the petri dish earth, 
      or the petri dish universe), it would be undetectable, not distinct from 
      any other organisms around, because an intelligent species would have to, 
      for purely selfish reasons, in order to succeed in the long term, care as 
      much about any other species as about itself. This paradoxical recipe for 
      success might not make sense to many humans today, but unless it does, we 
      cannot call ourselves "Homo sapient". Judging by our "success" we are 
      enjoying now at the expense of other life in our petri dish, we are not 
      enough "full of knowledge" yet. 
      Thank you, Hearthstone.
        
 
 |